Skip to content

Motivations for misinformation sharing

Psychological, social, and informational drivers behind why individuals share false or misleading information

Understanding why people share misinformation is central to modeling its spread and designing interventions. Research reveals a diverse set of motivations that extend far beyond simple belief: social signaling, entertainment, political debate, and even intentional debunking of falsehoods all drive sharing behavior.

Key distinctions

Intentional vs. unintentional: Most classic models assume people unknowingly share false claims they believe to be true (unintentional sharing). However, 8–17% of social media users admit to intentionally sharing news they suspected or knew to be false, motivated by sarcasm, testing others' credulity, political debate, or entertainment. This distinction is critical: a sharer's credibility signals (tone, framing, accompanying commentary) can tip recipients toward disbelief rather than belief.

Shared motivations across true and false news: People share both real and false news for identical reasons: social status (appearing well-informed), opinion leadership, emotional arousal, and relationship building. The same gratifications that drive viral true news also drive viral misinformation, complicating detection-by-motivation approaches.

Novel motivations unique to misinformation: Intentional sharing of known falsehoods introduces distinct motivations absent from true-news sharing:

  • Sarcasm and ridicule: Using absurd false claims to mock political opponents or highlight their supposed credulity.
  • Collective fact-checking: Sharing suspected misinformation to crowdsource its debunking and reduce uncertainty.
  • Education/warning: Deliberately broadcasting false claims with critical framing to warn others and signal one's own skepticism.
  • Debate and contention: Sharing provocative false claims to engage political dialogue, attract attention, or disrupt mainstream narratives.

Key papers

  • Metzger et al. (2021) — Comprehensive taxonomy of misinformation-sharing motivations drawn from news-sharing and rumor literature; empirically validates that people express widespread disbelief in false claims via commentary; proposes social commentary as a corrective mechanism analogous to Brandeis' "more speech" remedy.
  • Duffy, Tandoc & Ling (2019) — Examines both unintentional and intentional fake news sharing; identifies that unintentional sharing correlates with emotional impact and relevance (same as true news), while intentional sharing correlates with social media fatigue, fear of missing out, and desire for entertainment/debate.
  • Talwar et al. (2019) — Empirical study linking personality traits and social media behaviors to intentional fake news sharing; finds that self-disclosure, online trust, fear of missing out, and social media fatigue predict intentional sharing; establishes that high social media users are more likely to share false content knowingly.
  • Chadwick, Vaccari & O'Loughlin (2018) — Demonstrates that entertainment-seeking and debate-oriented sharers are significantly more likely to intentionally spread false news than those motivated by information or persuasion; frames this as "democratically dysfunctional" but notes some sharers see it as normative political engagement on social media.

Connections

  • News sharing behavior on social media — the broader phenomenon of which misinformation sharing is a subset.
  • Credibility assessment — how sharers' motivations (signaling disbelief vs. endorsement) influence recipients' evaluations of content.
  • Rumor cascades — historical research on rumors and gossip illuminates misinformation motivations (uncertainty reduction, relationship building, entertainment).
  • Political polarization — partisan motivations (supporting ingroup, attacking outgroup) drive much intentional misinformation sharing.

Papers on this topic